Home Assistant as a Standard Platform for Physiological Sensors?

Last Updated on October 22, 2022 by pg@petergamma.org

– We started our projects, and where first attracted by Matlab

– The advantages of Matlab are that it is well documented and has a support forum

– But again and again, we found opinions of experienced coders who wrote that Matlab is not worth it to buy, Python can do anything which Matlab can do

– Fur us, the Matlab support forum was an advantage

– Then Matlab supporter Adam Danz deleted all our Matlab questions out of the Matlab forum

with the comment «clearly a spammer»

– we are not interested in soft- and hardware developement, the Meditation Reserach Institute MRIS

is a private and non-commercial project on the level of a Swiss research institute, as it is published on our site

– Everybody is allowed to ask questions in the Matlab community, no Matlab licence is required for this

– Whe where shocked, and deeply hurt about this deletion

– We are still convinced that we will win this case agains Matlab supporter Adam Danz:

https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/profile/authors/25613423

– but it is time consuming and not worth it to this date.

– Then, questions about post deletion where deleted from the Matlab forum, another shock

– What is the motivation of this post deletion? Is it to reach a high Matlab score?

– The value of Matlab tropped for us dramatilly by this deletion acts

– Then, we found out, that a Matlab Home licence for about 200 USD cannot be used to publish data, a Matlab Standard Edition for arount 1000 USD is required for this

– With Matlab Standard, one can do only basic things, additional Matlab Toolboxes are required, which costs around 1000 USD each Toolbox as well

– Matlab is a bit better documented thant Python. But is it worth it to spend so much more for Matlab than for Python?

– Some physiological sensors like Apple watches, Fitbit devices, and Garmin watches over Strava can already be attached to Home Assistant

– Home Assistant is easier for mobile applications than Matlab

– What about attaching sensors directly to InfluxDB, and use Python only, without HA?

– There are many examples for InfluxDB, but most of them are difficult to understand

– There are more examples for Home Assistant

– Home Assistant is the second most active Python application

– Home Assistant is well documented

– for beginners probably easier than InfluxDB

– An alternative is the Python Client for InfuxDB

– There are examples available, how to read out temperature from a sensor every minute:

https://github.com/influxdata/influxdb-client-python#efficiency-write-data-from-iot-sensor

– Whether to use Matlab, Python, or InfluxDB? There is no general answer, we have to decide it case by case